Metamorphosis is generally considered one of the high-water marks of the European literary Modernism. We have collaborated on adapting a widely adaptable argument-based activity argument essay metamorphosis Argument Stations.
Argument Stations is an activity designed to teach curricular content through an argumentation framework. It is especially amenable to use as a pre-writing activity, preparing students to make developed arguments supporting their position, and respond to arguments that oppose their position. Identify and explain click at this page debatable issue for the unit.
The debatable issue should be an organizing navigational guide through opinion downloadable homework planner useful unit. The debatable issue for this project is an adapted version of what amounts to a near-universal question in the context of the study of literary masterworks:. Formulate and establish viable positions in response to the debatable issue.
The novel is fundamentally about the way that materialist values alienate us from our true selves. We lose touch with basic human kindness, joy of life, and empathy. Even when we see the problems of materialism, our attempts to escape fail argument essay metamorphosis materialism is everywhere. The attempt to escape becomes monstrous. The novel is fundamentally about the anxiety and argument essay metamorphosis mental illness that sexual repression causes in sensitive people, especially when sexuality is introduced as it so often is through article source family.
Trying to escape from forbidden sexuality, one becomes monstrous. The novel is fundamentally about the difficult choices that each individual must make in becoming an individual. The difficulty of making choices is magnified by the seeming meaninglessness of daily life in society.
Create an evidence set for use with this activity and possibly additional argument-based activities in the unit, including for instance an argument writing assessment. If the unit is built around a work of literature, the evidence set can be a Selected Passages document. The evidence set should have a roughly equal number of pieces of evidence supporting each go here the positions.
The evidence set for Metamorphosis picks out six of the most salient passages in the work for each of the three interpretive positions. Teach the unit content argument essay metamorphosis a manner that makes reference argument essay metamorphosis the position statements and the evidence set.
Curriculum vitae students see models of the use of evidence from the evidence set in thinking through the debatable argument essay metamorphosis. Start by assigning students roles.
There are two roles: Station Manager and Passage Holder. Station Managers should each receive a Station Manager Form, and they should each be assigned a position or interpretive reading.
An equal number of Station Managers should be assigned to each of the positions. The role of the Station Manager will be to respond to the passages brought to them by the Passage Holders. Passage Holders should each be assigned a passage from the evidence set.
They should receive a Passage Holder Form. Passage Holders should take their passage and their form to a Station representing each of the viable positions. The Passage Holder should then respond to this reasoning, agreeing with it but adding to it, disagreeing argument essay metamorphosis it and argument essay metamorphosis alternative reasoning, or critiquing the reasoning in some way. The Passage Holder should complete their form, by going around to the Stations that represent each position.
The Passage Holder might need some time away from the Stations to complete their responses on the form. The Station Manager should use any down time between visits from Passage Holders to complete their form.
The activity can end with students submitting their forms. You can also conduct a discussion, either before they are submitted or after they are turned back, generated by the argumentation made in the speaking and writing that the activity required.
Click here to download the Argument Stations format. Method and Procedure 1 Identify and explain a debatable issue for the unit. The Marxist Interpretive Position. The Freudian Interpretive Position. The Existentialist Interpretive Position. Click here to download the Station Manager form. Click here to download a Passage Holder form. Debatifier Categories Argument essay metamorphosis and Literacy. Argumentative Writing. Argument click here Science.
Argument link Math. Classroom Debating. Common Core. Guest Posts. Professional Capacity Development. Generous support for this website provided by Betty J. Willhoite and her late husband Argument essay metamorphosis J. Website design by kuraldesign.